GOP Showdown: Candidate Rejects Governor’s Push to Drop Out

Hands typing on a backlit keyboard in darkness

Virginia’s GOP lieutenant governor candidate John Reid is defying Governor Glenn Youngkin’s call to drop out following controversy over a social media account allegedly linked to him containing explicit photos.

Key Takeaways

John Reid, the first openly gay Republican to run statewide in Virginia, refuses to withdraw from the lieutenant governor race despite pressure from Governor Youngkin.
The controversy centers on a Tumblr account with explicit photos that had a username matching Reid’s Instagram handle, which Reid vehemently denies creating.
Reid became the sole Republican candidate after his primary opponent Pat Herrity dropped out for health reasons.
The timing of the controversy is significant, emerging just before early voting begins in Virginia’s primaries.
The situation highlights growing tensions within the Republican Party regarding social conservatism and LGBTQ+ representation.

Reid Stands Firm Against Pressure to Exit Race

John Reid, who would make history as Virginia’s first openly gay statewide officeholder if elected, is refusing to bow to pressure from Governor Glenn Youngkin to abandon his campaign for lieutenant governor. The controversy erupted when a Tumblr account sharing explicit photos was reportedly linked to Reid through a username matching his Instagram handle. Reid has categorically denied any connection to the account, characterizing it as a fabricated attempt to discredit him because of his sexual orientation.

In a defiant response to the governor’s request, Reid expressed disappointment that Youngkin would call for his resignation without substantial evidence. “I’m mad as hell,” Reid stated in a recent interview, rejecting the allegations as baseless attacks designed to force him out of the race. The timing of these allegations is particularly noteworthy, coming shortly before early voting begins in Virginia’s primary elections.

Political Implications for Virginia Republicans

The controversy has significant implications for the Republican Party in Virginia. Reid became the sole GOP candidate for lieutenant governor after his only opponent, Pat Herrity, withdrew from the race citing health concerns. This development leaves Republicans in a difficult position, with concerns about potentially alienating conservative Christian voters who form a crucial support base for the party in Virginia.

Governor Youngkin’s call for Reid’s resignation aligns with the position of the conservative Family Foundation Action group, highlighting tensions within the party between traditional social conservative values and efforts to broaden Republican appeal. Reid has also faced criticism from within his party for his attendance at a drag show, further complicating his candidacy in the eyes of some conservative supporters.

Virginia’s GOP lieutenant governor race heats up: a candidate says Gov. Youngkin pressured him to quit over a smear campaign. Here’s what happened: https://t.co/d47hUbRfiE

— WUSA9 (@wusa9) April 26, 2025

Digital Footprint Under Scrutiny

The controversy surrounding Reid underscores the increasing scrutiny politicians face regarding their online activities and digital footprints. According to reports from The Richmonder, the Tumblr account in question was deleted after reposting photos of naked men. Reid maintains that the account was created specifically to spread falsehoods about him due to his sexuality, suggesting a targeted campaign to undermine his historic candidacy.

This case draws parallels to a similar situation involving Virginia Democrat Susanna Gibson, highlighting how digital controversies can affect candidates across the political spectrum. As politicians’ online presences receive increased attention, the boundaries between personal activities and public service continue to blur, creating new challenges for candidates and parties alike.

Path Forward for Virginia Republicans

With Reid standing firm in his decision to remain in the race and early voting approaching, Virginia Republicans face difficult decisions about how to navigate this controversy. Governor Youngkin, who initially supported Reid, has now distanced himself from the candidate. This situation creates uncertainty for the party as it prepares for the upcoming election cycle in a battleground state where President Trump’s influence remains significant.

The outcome of this internal Republican conflict may signal broader trends about the party’s direction on social issues and its approach to diversity within its ranks. As Virginia’s primaries draw closer, the resolution of this standoff between Reid and party leadership will be closely watched for its implications on Republican unity heading into the general election.