New Jersey Governor Murphy Pardons Women Convicted of Partner Murders Amid Justice Reform Efforts

Pardon spelled with wooden letter tiles blocks

New Jersey Governor Philip D. Murphy pardons three women convicted of murdering their abusive partners, marking his first use of clemency powers in office.

At a Glance

  • Gov. Murphy commuted sentences of three women convicted of killing abusive partners
  • These are Murphy’s first pardons in his two-term administration
  • A clemency advisory panel was established six months ago to review cases
  • The pardons are part of Murphy’s broader justice reform efforts
  • 33 additional individuals received pardons for various offenses

Governor Murphy’s Unprecedented Clemency Action

New Jersey Governor Philip D. Murphy has taken a significant step in criminal justice reform by granting clemency to three women convicted of murdering their abusive partners. This action marks the first use of his pardoning power since taking office in 2018. The women, Myrna Diaz, Dawn Jackson, and Denise Staples, are expected to be released by Wednesday, ending their lengthy incarcerations.

Murphy’s decision comes as part of a broader initiative to address inequities in the criminal justice system. The governor described this as “the most momentous day” of his tenure, signaling a shift towards a more compassionate approach to justice.

A New Approach to Clemency

Six months ago, Murphy established a clemency advisory panel to review cases deserving of pardons or sentence commutations. This panel focuses on nonviolent offenders and individuals who were victims of domestic or sexual violence. The creation of this board represents a significant change in how clemency decisions are made in New Jersey.

“This is about the most momentous day I’ve had as governor” – Mr. Murphy

Unlike his predecessors, Murphy waited until late in his second term to grant pardons. This delay allowed for the careful consideration of cases and the establishment of a fair and impartial process. Justin Dews, chairman of the advisory board, emphasized that fairness, not favor, is now the guiding principle behind the governor’s clemency decisions.

Broader Implications for Criminal Justice Reform

Murphy’s actions are part of a larger trend among Democratic governors using clemency to address specific groups of offenders. Similar initiatives have been seen in Oregon, Massachusetts, and Maryland, particularly regarding marijuana-related offenses. In New Jersey, the legalization of cannabis has allowed for the expungement of certain marijuana-related criminal records.

“We rededicate ourselves to ensuring that New Jersey is this state for second chances.” – Gov. Phil Murphy

The governor’s office has emphasized that these clemency actions are about addressing past injustices and promoting second chances. The ACLU of New Jersey, which represented the three women, supports clemency by crime category as a means to address systemic injustice.

Looking Ahead

With his term ending in January 2026 and unable to seek re-election due to term limits, Murphy has promised more similar actions in the coming months. This commitment suggests a concerted effort to leave a lasting impact on New Jersey’s criminal justice system.

“We will have more days like this over the next 13 months. I promise you.” – Mr. Murphy https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/16/nyregion/phil-murphy-new-jersey-pardons.html

While these pardons have been met with support from justice reform advocates, they also raise questions about the long-term implications of such actions. As the state moves towards a more “survivor-centric” approach to justice, it remains to be seen how these changes will impact public safety and the overall criminal justice system in New Jersey.

Sources:

  1. Gov. Murphy Grants First Pardons, Freeing 3 Women Convicted of Murder
  2. Gov. Murphy pardons 33 and commutes 3 women’s sentences in first use of clemency
  3. Gov. Murphy Grants First Pardons, Freeing 3 Women Convicted of Murder

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR